Loved the vibe in the Peacock Room, so much character! Our waitress was super sweet and on top of everything. The prime rib was a solid choice, really tender. Perfect spot for catching up with the girls.

Upstairs terrace is the place to be. Grabbed a beer and caught some live music. It was a good vibe for a casual Thursday night. The trivia night looked fun too, might check that out next time.

Had to wait a bit for a table on a busy Saturday, but the vibe inside was really nice. The lighting was soft and the booths were super comfortable. Made the wait feel okay.

Been coming here for years. Their pumpkin soup is always good - nice and creamy, not too sweet. It&#39;s the one thing I order every time.

Been coming here for years. The prime rib sandwich with au jus is solid, and the fries are always crispy. Staff is friendly, they even held the door. A good, reliable spot in the neighborhood.

As someone who&#39;s lived here for years, I can say Nic&#39;s is the real deal. The flavors are authentic and the cooking is spot on.

First time trying their pizza. Got a pepperoni and a margherita. Crust was perfect, really good flavor. The place is clean and modern. Wish they had cannoli though.

Perfect for a quick bite in Jerome. The owner makes the Mr. Egg Sandwich on a bagel himself. Fast and tasty.

Fun haunted house vibe in a historic building. The decor is cool and fits the theme well. Good for a casual dinner with friends. Food was decent, nothing spectacular but service was efficient.

The brisket is the reason to come. It&#39;s so tender and the flavor is deep. They have a few house-made BBQ sauces, and the jalape&ntilde;o molasses one is my favorite with it.

The Reuben was really fresh, and the Russian dressing worked so well with the pastrami on that grilled sourdough. The bar area is a nice little spot to hang out. Solid lunch.

Stumbled upon this place and had to try the burger. Asked for well-done, and they nailed it&mdash;still managed to keep it juicy. Paired it with a local IPA that cut through the richness nicely. Solid spot for a straightforward, satisfying meal.

No reservation on a Saturday, but they got us in fast. The hostess was so chill about it, just a quick smile and led us to a little corner table. Felt lucky, not rushed at all.

Gyros and the Chipotle burger with jalape&ntilde;o bacon were solid. The brownie dessert is a good size for two. Service was efficient, got our food quickly. Decent spot for a straightforward lunch.

Been coming here for years. Always grab a seat at the bar to watch the chefs work. It&rsquo;s the main reason I keep coming back.

The gluten-free pasta here is actually pretty solid. Had the fettuccine alfredo, sauce was creamy without being too heavy. They&#39;ve got a decent selection for that diet, which is nice.

A solid choice for a home-style meal. The pot roast was pretty good, and the portions are generous. The bear decor is cute.

The server was so kind and helpful. She really took her time explaining the menu and suggested a few dishes based on what we were in the mood for. It felt personal, not rushed at all.

The spicy margarita here is my new favorite. It&rsquo;s got a nice kick but still feels light and refreshing. The presentation was so pretty, I had to snap a photo before my first sip. 😄

Been coming here for years, and their Reuben is still the real deal. The corned beef is house-made, not too salty, and the kraut cuts through the richness just right. Sweet potato fries are crispy. It&rsquo;s my go-to lunch spot.

The staff was so kind and attentive. Our drinks were refilled before we even noticed they were low.

The owner was here tonight, checking on tables and chatting. It&rsquo;s nice to see someone so hands-on. My pasta was solid, but honestly, that personal touch is what I&rsquo;ll remember.

Solid spot for a quick lunch. The retro vibe is cool. Food came out fast, which is key for me. Burger was juicy, fries crispy. A bit pricey for what it is, but convenient.

Tried the breakfast reuben with eggs, corned beef, and hollandaise. It was a solid choice, and the seasoned potatoes were good. For the price though, I wish the portion was a bit bigger.

Server was on point. Knew the menu inside out, gave solid suggestions without hovering. Made the whole thing smooth and quick. Exactly what you want for a fast lunch.

Green chile burrito was the real deal. Smoky, spicy, not too heavy. That&#39;s the one to get. The burger looked good too, but the burrito hit the spot.

Birthday dinner here. Cozy spot, perfect for a small group. Food tasted super fresh, you can tell it&#39;s made from scratch. Had to wait a bit even with a reservation, but no biggie.

Been coming here for years. The hoagie rolls are still perfect, crunchy crust and all. They use shredded cabbage, not lettuce, so it stays crisp. My only gripe? Wish they had a better beer selection to go with these hefty sandwiches.

Your ultimate guide to dining in Mayer. Discover top-rated restaurants and local favorites, based on authentic traveler ratings and reviews. ▸ See menus & photos ▸ Find hidden gems ▸ Plan your perfect trip.

The best restaurants in Mayer

Peacock Dining Room - Hassayampa Inn

Raven Cafe

BackBurner Family Restaurant

Manzanita Restaurant

Tavern Grille

Nic's Italian Steak & Crab House

Pizzeria Bocce

The Flatiron Café

Haunted Hamburger

Bobby D's BBQ

The Miner’s Café

G's Burgers

El Gato Azul

Gurley St Grill

Atmesfir

Marino's Mob Burgers and Ice Cream

Black Bear Diner Cottonwood

Limoncello Pizzeria Napoletana

The Barley Hound

Farm Provisions

Plaza Bonita | Mexican Restaurant

Verde Lea Market Deli & Grill

Bing's Burger Station

Old Town Red Rooster Cafe

Asylum Restaurant

b. simple

Torme

Lynx Lake Cafe

Maya's Restaurant

Nick's Feed Your Face