Trip
Travel guides
North America
United States
New York State
Suffolk County
Trip.com Gourmet Awards
Recommended Restaurants in Brookhaven for October

The best restaurants in Brookhaven

Opening hours

Open Now
0:00 AM～5:00 AM
5:00 AM～10:00 AM
10:00 AM～2:00 PM

Updated in October 2026

Painters' Restaurant

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-16:00, 16:00-22:00)
133m from downtown

Varney's Restaurant

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-20:00)
1.4 km from downtown

Lombardi's on the Bay

4.1/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Seafood
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-22:00)
1.1 km from downtown

Eckart's Luncheonette

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow08:00-15:00)
8.8 km from downtown

Stone Creek Inn

4.8/5
Amazing
5 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow17:30-22:00)
638m from downtown

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar

4.4/5
Great
5 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-21:00)
1.8 km from downtown

Bistro 72

4.1/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Seafood
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow10:00-15:00, 15:00-23:00)
2.5 km from downtown

Butera's - Woodbury

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-16:00, 16:30-21:30)
6.6 km from downtown

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

4.4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Seafood
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-15:45, 16:30-21:00)
557m from downtown

Chachama Grill

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow16:00-21:00)
758m from downtown

Volpe Restaurant

4.6/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow17:00-22:00)
5.6 km from downtown

Tweed's Restaurant

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Seafood
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-21:00)
17m from downtown

North Sea Tavern

4.1/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-23:00)
528m from downtown

Maroni Cuisine

4.7/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow16:00-23:00)

Feed and Grain

4/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow16:00-22:00)

The Cheesecake Factory

4.2/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-22:00)
2 km from downtown

Orto

4.7/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow17:00-21:30)
916m from downtown

Corner Galley

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-22:00)
11.6 km from downtown

Bin 100 Restaurant

4.6/5
Amazing
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow16:00-22:00)
3 km from downtown

RACHEL’S Restaurant & Bakery

4.3/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Closing soon (06:30-Next day00:00)
73m from downtown

Dockers Waterside Marina & Restaurant

4.1/5
Great
7 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-21:00)
1.4 km from downtown

Piccola Bussola Ristorante

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed
1.4 km from downtown

The Village Cheese Shop

4.8/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Coffee shop
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow10:00-17:00)
51m from downtown

75 Main

4/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Closing soon (16:00-23:45)
72m from downtown

Bistro 44

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Bars/bistros
$$-$$$
Currently closed

Cooperage Inn

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-20:00)
10 km from downtown

Sandbar

4.5/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Seafood
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow12:00-22:00)
261m from downtown

Local Burger - Bay Shore Restaurant and Bar

4.7/5
Amazing
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:30-22:00)
132m from downtown

Shake Shack Lake Grove

4.2/5
Great
6 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed
1.6 km from downtown

Zorn's of Bethpage

4.5/5
Great
4 reviews
󱵁Western cuisine
$$-$$$
Currently closed (Tomorrow11:00-20:00)
723m from downtown