Searching for hotels in Fire Island? Compare room rates and reviews to find your ideal stay.

Recommended Fire Island Hotels

Check out our selection of great hotels in Fire Island.

Business travel

Show more

Breakfast

Show more

Family friendly

Show more

Hotels near Popular Attractions in Fire Island

Check out these hotels located near popular sights in Fire Island

Seaview Market

Show more

Fire Island Lighthouse

Show more

Great South Beach

Clarion Hotel and Conference Center
2.5/5100 Reviews

Clarion Hotel and Conference Center

Ronkonkoma
The front desk staff was nice and accommodating. The owners however, were the rudest I have met. Every time the owner was behind the counter, she was yelling at someone. She was condescending, poorly organized, and just mean at time. 1. I had overslept and so she said she was going to charge me a late checkout fee. Fine. I said, I will book the room for an additional night to make up for it. Once it as booked, she then said she was going to charge me the late checkout fee of $50 AND the additional night which I thought was completely insane. I would have just accepted the late checkout and been on my way. Not to mention, how she communicated was completely aggressive. I asked to speak to management, and she kindly advised me that she was management and that she's the owner and that there was nothing that I could do about it. (smirked and smiled as she walked off). 2. The hotel provides microwaves (sometimes??) but no plates to warm anything else in. I was referred to the gas station next door. They also did not have any plates 3. So she then makes me come all the way to the front desk to sign the deposit form again (mind you, the hotel is a huge maze of rooms and halls and I was at the back). It takes about 5min to walk to the front. She then allows me, to walk all the way back to my room, only for the keys to be turned off. I have to walk all the way back to the front desk, and she laughs and then gives me the key replacement. She intentionally did not let me know about the keys needing to be reactivated. Just all around disappointing and unnecessary. If you are this miserable, why work in the hospitality field
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
4.2/5103 Reviews

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma
I stayed here for two nights on a business trip. I’m a loyal Hilton guest but this was my first time staying at this particular hotel. Staff were super friendly throughout my stay and my room was large, airy and very clean, though the floor of my bathroom was a tad sticky and the lighting in the room is poor unless you turn on all the lights… I slept like a baby on both nights — it was super quiet at night (though you can hear people in their rooms as you walk down the corridors), the bed was suuuuuper comfortable and the room temperature just right! I still remain surprised at the lack of recycling efforts in guest rooms (a downfall of most Hiltons, unfortunately) and I was also surprised at the lack of toiletries provided in the bathroom (see photo).……..and the shower was in a very strange position — you had to squeeze in next to the toilet in order to open the sliding door and turn on the tap, else go fully into the shower from the other end and get wet whilst you turn it on. Very poor engineering! All this aside, my stay was overall a good one — and I’d no doubt stay here again — but there were two things that didn’t fly well with me (two things that may be fine for others!) 1. They have a VERY small gym — small especially for the size of the hotel. When I tried to use it on the first morning of my stay (around 6.15am) it was already “packed” and only one treadmill was working. I ended up leaving as there simply wasn’t any room for another person. There’s also no water or water fountain in the gym (I asked reception about where I could fill my bottle and they said they didn’t have anywhere to do this — so make sure you take a full bottle into the gym with you!), there’s no hand sanitizer, and there were no gym towels on the second morning of my stay. As someone who chooses their hotel based in part on access to a decent fitness center, this was a disappointing part of my stay. 2. There was a strong smell of cigarette smoke on the first floor — I’m very grateful I was staying on the 4th floor!

Show more

Robert Moses State Park

Show more

Frequently Asked Questions

  • How do I book a hotel on Trip.com?

    To book a hotel on Trip.com, simply enter your destination, travel dates, and the number of guests on the page. Then, browse through the available hotels and select the one you want to book. Follow the prompts to enter your payment information and complete the booking.

  • How to get hotel deals on Trip.com?

    There are several ways to discover affordable hotels on Trip.com. You can narrow down your search results by filtering hotels according to your preferred price range, or you can sort the results by price to view the least expensive options first.

  • Where can I find hotel deals on Trip.com?

    Trip.com offers a diverse selection of hotel deals and promotions that are available throughout the year. You can easily find these special offers on our deals page. Moreover, if you are a member of our loyalty program, you can log in to your account and discover exclusive discounted rates at hotel list pages.

  • How to get lower prices for hotels?

    Sometimes booking hotels in midweek is cheaper, but it also depends on the season.

  • How many hotels are listed on Trip.com?

    There are over 5,000,000 hotels in more than 230 countries or regions on Trip.com. Haven't decided which hotel to book? Browse our site to get ideas!

  • Can I cancel or change my hotel bookings on Trip.com?

    It depends on the hotel policy and date of cancellation. Kindly check the policy section of related hotel pages. To cancel or change your bookings, log in to your Trip.com account, go to "My Bookings", and follow the instructions.

  • How do I contact Trip.com's customer support?

    You can contact Trip.com's 24/7 customer support by visiting the Help Center on Trip.com and submitting a request. You can also contact by phone or service chat, depending on your location.

Hotels Quick Overview

Highest PriceS$ 861
Lowest PriceS$ 167
Number of Reviews54
Number of Hotels9
Average Price (Weekdays)S$ 335
Average Price (Weekends)S$ 400

More About Fire Island

Book hotels in Fire Island via the Trip.com website or app, it's easy and hassle-free. Book your hotel on Trip.com for an amazing travel experience.

There is no civilian airport in this city. You can visit a nearby city first, and then head to Fire Island using other means of transportation. Visitors often choose to travel to Fire Island by bus.

When looking for hotels in Fire Island, there are likely good options at a nightly budget of just 392 SGD. There are not many well-known chain hotels in Fire Island, but staying at a unique local hotel will make you feel at home. Lover's & Other Strangers is one of the most popular hotels in Fire Island.

The most famous attractions locally are Robert Moses State Park, Fire Island Lighthouse, Surfs Out, Kismet.

Show less